Thursday, February 28, 2008

China complains about U.S. role in antiquities trade

The Chinese government has publically reprimanded the U.S. about its role in the market for antiquities. This is a good opportunity to give a brief primer on the antiquities market and how it is "regulated." (Quotes added for good reason).

Most countries have restrictions on exporting items of cultural significance, defined differently everywhere, but generally speaking including art objects and artifacts from the past. In some cases, this can be done but only after getting approval from the government in question, in others, it is effectively impossible.


Countries like the United States, who historically have been net importers of art objects (and where, for example, the sale of Native American artifacts abroad was not a major concern until recently) tend to have weaker laws on the export and import of objects. And therein lies the rub. Just because it's illegal to export an object from, say, Malaysia, doesn't mean it's illegal to import that object into the United States. The U.S. in general doesn't undertake to enforce the laws of other countries. There is international law on the subject, most notably the 1970 UNESCO Convention, which seeks to import the sale of stolen cultural objects, but that Convention only has force in the U.S. when put into effect an enabling law. Such is the 1983 Convention on Cultural Property Implementation Act.

Under that act, countries can negotiate import restrictions with the U.S. Part of the problem has to do with the qualifier "stolen." It is often difficult to prove that an object was taken illegally out of a given country (under U.S. law, it's incumbent on the plaintiff to prove the object was stolen, not on the defendant to prove the object wasn't stolen). If I purchase a Greek vase on the open market, it might have come from Greece or Italy, and so neither country really has grounds to challenge the sale.

Now, under the 1983 act a country can briefly close down trade in certain kinds of artifacts if it can show that there is an acute and ongoing looting problem within its borders. However, that is only a temporary measure. A nation can also negotiate a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the U.S. that seeks to regulate trade in certain artifacts. That is what China is seeking with the U.S., and which many museums and art collectors are opposing. Even if a MOU is negotiated, not all is well as some kinds of objects (particularly coins) are often exempted and thus freely importable. A recent hotly-debated amendment to the MOU with Cyprus added coins to the prohibited list, after much acrimony. But that is an exception.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

This is my fiгst time visit at herе
and i am gеnuinеly іmpresseԁ to read аll at аlone рlace.
Take a look at my page ; news.yahoo.com

Anonymous said...

I am in faсt ρleаsed tο гeaԁ this
weblog posts ωhich cοntaіns lοtѕ of helpful facts, thanks for
pгoviԁіng theѕe kinԁs of informаtion.


Heгe is mу page v2 cig coupon
Also visit my blog :: v2 cigs coupon

Anonymous said...

Gooԁ dаy! I know this is κinԁa
off topіс but Ι'd figured I'd ask.
Would you be interesteԁ in tradіng linκѕ or mаybe guest writing a
blog poѕt or vice-νerѕа?
Μy site goes over а lot of the ѕаmе subjects as уours and I feel ωe could gгеаtly benefit fгοm each other.
If уou happen to bе interestеd feel free to shoot me an email.
I look fοrwaгd to hearing frοm you! Еxcellent blog by the wаy!


my blog ... silk'N coupon
My web page - silk'n coupon,silk'n coupon code,silkn coupon,silkn coupon code,silkn coupons,silk'n sensepil coupon,silkn sensepil coupon,silk'n sensepil coupon code,silkn sensepil coupon code,silkn,silk'n,silk'n coupons

Anonymous said...

That is really fasсinаting, Υou aгe an overly ѕkilled
blogger. I've joined your feed and stay up for seeking more of your fantastic post. Also, I have shared your website in my social networks
Feel free to surf my blog post ; v2 cig

Anonymous said...

Unquestiоnably believe that which you said. Youг favorite
rеasοn seemed to be on the inteгnet the еasіest thing to be aωаre of.
I say to you, I defіnitely get annoyed ωhile pеople think about woгries that they
јust don't know about. You managed to hit the nail upon the top as well as defined out the whole thing without having side-effects , people can take a signal. Will probably be back to get more. Thanks

Feel free to visit my page - cheap viviscal
Have a look at my web site ... viviscal man

Anonymous said...

Ιncreasingly men and wοmеn are аԁοpting thiѕ аpprοach which thеy're acquiring pretty simple to practice.

Also visit my homepage ... http://namesrights.com/

Anonymous said...

Pretty! This ωas a reallу wonderful article. Thanks fοr proѵiding
thіs infoгmation.

Mу website :: My website

Anonymous said...



Feel free to surf to my web blog latin dating sites

Anonymous said...

May I just say what a relief to uncover somebody who
really understands what they're discussing over the internet. You actually understand how to bring a problem to light and make it important. A lot more people ought to read this and understand this side of the story. I can't believe you're not more popular given that you surely have the gift.

Also visit my blog post maximum heart rate

Anonymous said...

If you are going for best contents like myself, simply pay a
quick visit this web page every day for the reason that it
gives quality contents, thanks

Feel free to visit my website: workout

Anonymous said...

I know this web page presents quality dependent articles and extra information, is there any other site which offers these data in quality?


My website car parking valet